Best Practices for Packaging Apps with InstallAware Express for Windows Installer

Troubleshooting InstallAware Express for Windows Installer: Common Issues & FixesInstallAware Express for Windows Installer is a lightweight packaging tool designed to create MSI-based installers quickly. Like any software, it can present issues during installation authoring, build, or deployment. This article covers common problems users encounter with InstallAware Express and provides practical fixes, diagnostic tips, and preventative best practices.


1. Installer Fails to Build or Compile

Symptoms

  • Build process halts with errors.
  • Generated MSI is missing or unusable.
  • Build log shows script or resource errors.

Common Causes and Fixes

  • Missing files referenced in the project.
    Fix: Verify all file paths in your project. Use relative paths or ensure absolute paths exist on the build machine. Check the Build Log for “file not found” messages.

  • Syntax or script errors in the InstallAware script.
    Fix: Open the script editor and validate syntax. Use smaller incremental builds after changes to isolate the problematic section.

  • Out-of-date or corrupt InstallAware installation.
    Fix: Repair or reinstall InstallAware Express. Ensure you’re using a supported version for your OS and Visual Studio (if integrated).

Diagnostics

  • Review the build log located in the project’s output folder. Look for error codes and line numbers.
  • Reproduce the build on a clean machine to rule out local environment issues.

2. MSI Fails During Installation on Target Machines

Symptoms

  • MSI aborts with Windows Installer errors (e.g., 1603, 1618).
  • Installation hangs or rolls back.
  • Features fail to install.

Common Causes and Fixes

  • Insufficient permissions.
    Fix: Run the MSI as Administrator. Ensure target user has rights to write to Program Files and HKLM registry keys.

  • Existing MSI or installer conflict (error 1618).
    Fix: Ensure no other MSI-based installation is running. Use task manager to kill msiexec.exe or schedule the new install after other installers complete.

  • Custom actions failing.
    Fix: Log custom action output. Convert immediate custom actions when possible or ensure deferred actions have access to required data via CustomActionData.

  • Files in use or locked files causing rollback (error 1603).
    Fix: Close applications using those files or schedule a restart. Use the Windows Installer property REBOOT=ReallySuppress cautiously.

Diagnostics

  • Enable verbose MSI logging: msiexec /i “YourInstaller.msi” /l*v install.log. Inspect install.log for detailed error messages and return codes.
  • Check Event Viewer (Application/System) for MSI-related entries.

3. Registry Entries Not Created or Incorrect

Symptoms

  • Application settings missing after installation.
  • COM registration fails.
  • Product doesn’t behave as expected.

Common Causes and Fixes

  • Wrong registry hive (HKCU vs HKLM).
    Fix: Decide whether the entry should be per-user or per-machine and author the component accordingly. For per-machine installs, write to HKLM and ensure elevated privileges.

  • Components not associated with a key file.
    Fix: Every component should have a key path. Associate the registry entries with a component that has a stable key file to ensure proper installation and uninstallation.

  • 64-bit vs 32-bit registry redirection.
    Fix: Mark components as 64-bit when writing to 64-bit registry hives, and build a 64-bit package if necessary.

Diagnostics

  • Use regedit on the target machine to verify expected keys.
  • Check Component and Feature tables (if comfortable using Orca or MSI database tools) to confirm registry entries are correctly authored.

4. Shortcuts, File Associations, or COM Objects Missing

Symptoms

  • No desktop/start menu shortcuts after install.
  • File types aren’t associated with the app.
  • COM servers aren’t registered.

Common Causes and Fixes

  • Components with no key path or incorrect installation condition.
    Fix: Ensure shortcut and association components have key files and are tied to installed features.

  • Per-user vs per-machine mismatch.
    Fix: Avoid creating per-user shortcuts during a per-machine install unless specifically intended. Use the appropriate INSTALLLEVEL and conditions.

  • COM registration happens during install but fails due to permission or platform mismatch.
    Fix: Register COM objects under the correct bitness and with elevated privileges. Consider using self-registration only if necessary; prefer writing registry entries directly for reliability.

Diagnostics

  • Check the Shortcut and Class tables in the MSI via MSI database tools.
  • Confirm COM entries exist in the registry and that DLL/OCX files are present in the expected locations.

5. Upgrade, Repair, or Uninstall Problems

Symptoms

  • New version of MSI doesn’t upgrade older installs.
  • Repair does not restore missing files.
  • Uninstall leaves residual files or registry entries.

Common Causes and Fixes

  • Incorrect ProductCode/ProductVersion/UpgradeCode handling.
    Fix: Follow Windows Installer rules: change ProductCode for major upgrades, keep UpgradeCode consistent, and increment ProductVersion appropriately. Use InstallAware’s upgrade project features to author Major/Minor upgrades.

  • Components with changing component codes or wrong key paths.
    Fix: Keep component GUIDs stable for unchanged components; ensure key paths remain constant.

  • Custom uninstall actions leaving residues.
    Fix: Avoid custom actions that delete files or registry keys outside the MSI component management; instead, author components so Windows Installer handles cleanup.

Diagnostics

  • Inspect the Upgrade table and RemoveExistingProducts scheduling. Test upgrade scenarios in a clean VM.
  • Use logs for install/repair/uninstall: msiexec /i app.msi /l*v install.log; msiexec /x {ProductCode} /l*v uninstall.log.

6. Silent or Unattended Installations Fail

Symptoms

  • MSI hangs or requires UI during silent installs.
  • Install exits with codes but not all components are installed.

Common Causes and Fixes

  • Custom actions expecting UI input.
    Fix: Ensure custom actions can run without UI or add appropriate command-line properties to supply needed values.

  • Features conditioned on UI properties.
    Fix: Rework conditions to rely on properties settable via the command line (e.g., PROPERTY=Value) and documented for silent installs.

  • Incorrect command-line syntax.
    Fix: Use msiexec with proper switches, for example: msiexec /i “Your.msi” /qn /l*v “install.log” PROPERTY=Value.

Diagnostics

  • Capture verbose logs to see where the installation stops waiting.
  • Test with /qb (basic UI) then /qn (no UI) to identify UI-dependent steps.

7. Licensing, Serial Keys, or Activation Failures

Symptoms

  • Installer accepts keys but application rejects them.
  • Activation fails post-install.

Common Causes and Fixes

  • License stored in per-user location while install is per-machine.
    Fix: Store license/activation data in a location appropriate for the intended scope (per-user vs per-machine) and provide migration logic if upgrading a per-user install to per-machine.

  • Activation requires network access or delayed service start.
    Fix: Ensure activation steps occur after network is available. If activation is part of the first run, consider deferring to application runtime rather than installer.

Diagnostics

  • Review installer logic and when/where it stores license information.
  • Test activation on machines with restricted network access to reproduce issues.

8. Build Machine or CI/CD Integration Issues

Symptoms

  • Automated builds fail or produce inconsistent MSIs.
  • Missing certificates for signing.

Common Causes and Fixes

  • Environment differences between dev and CI systems.
    Fix: Keep a reproducible build environment: same OS, SDKs, and InstallAware version. Store dependencies in source control or package manager.

  • Code signing certificate absent or inaccessible on CI.
    Fix: Provision signing certificates securely on CI (use secure variables or certificate stores) and update signing commands in the build script.

Diagnostics

  • Run builds with verbose logging and compare outputs locally vs CI.
  • Use containerized build agents or dedicated build VMs to reduce environment drift.

9. Digital Signature / Code Signing Problems

Symptoms

  • Windows SmartScreen warns about unknown publisher.
  • Signature invalid or missing.

Common Causes and Fixes

  • Certificate expired or not chained to a recognized root.
    Fix: Renew certificates and ensure the chain is complete. Timestamp signatures so they remain valid after expiry.

  • Wrong signing algorithm or not signing the final MSI.
    Fix: Sign the final output MSI with SHA-256 and include a timestamp server. Automate signing after the build completes.

Diagnostics

  • Use signtool verify /pa YourInstaller.msi to check signatures.
  • Test on clean machines to observe SmartScreen behavior.

10. Performance or Large Installer Size Issues

Symptoms

  • Installer size too large.
  • Installation takes excessive time.

Common Causes and Fixes

  • Including unnecessary files or uncompressed resources.
    Fix: Exclude development artifacts, compress resources, and use media merging or external downloads for large content.

  • Inefficient custom actions that perform heavy work during install.
    Fix: Move expensive operations to first-run application code or background services instead of the installer.

Diagnostics

  • Inspect contents of the MSI with Orca or other MSI tools to see included files.
  • Time individual actions with logging to find slow steps.

Preventative Best Practices

  • Use version control for InstallAware projects and scripts.
  • Test installs in clean VMs representing target OS versions (x86/x64, Windows 10/11/Server).
  • Enable verbose logging during testing and retain logs for troubleshooting.
  • Prefer MSI-native mechanisms (components, key paths, standard tables) over self-registration or ad-hoc custom actions.
  • Keep component GUIDs stable and manage UpgradeCode/ProductCode according to Windows Installer rules.
  • Automate builds and signing in CI with reproducible environments.
  • Document properties and command-line switches for silent installs.

Quick Diagnostic Checklist

  • Run msiexec with /l*v to get a verbose log.
  • Confirm correct privileges (run as Administrator).
  • Check Event Viewer for related errors.
  • Verify file/registry paths and component key paths.
  • Test in clean VM and reproduce step-by-step.
  • Ensure certificate and signing are correct.

If you want, I can:

  • Analyze a specific verbose install log you provide and point out likely causes.
  • Create a checklist or template for InstallAware projects to prevent common mistakes.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *